Dr Anandhan's MINDCARE

Lack of technology; not evidence

Why the absence of a laboratory test does not make mental illness less real

By Dr Anandhan Panneerselvam, MBBS, DPM, FIPS · Consultant Psychiatrist

Psychiatry is a branch of medicine, like endocrinology or rheumatology. Psychology is a science, like biology or physiology. It has been an experimental science since Wilhelm Wundt opened his laboratory in Leipzig in 1879. Many of our universities, which once awarded a BA and MA in psychology, now award a BSc and MSc. The label has caught up with the subject.

Yet many scholars and scientists in other fields still picture something else. To them, psychology and psychiatry mean hypnotism, the unconscious mind, and violent or bizarre behaviour. They accept diabetes and hypothyroidism as real diseases because there is a number on a report. They doubt depression and bipolar disorder because there is none.

ILLNESSLABORATORY TEST
Diabetes● Blood sugar
Hypothyroidism● Thyroid hormone
Depression○ No lab test yet
Bipolar disorder○ No lab test yet
All four are real illnesses.

This doubt confuses two different things: evidence that an illness exists, and a test that can show it in one patient.

Medicine has always diagnosed first and measured later. Diabetes was recognised for centuries by thirst, wasting and sweet urine. Hypothyroidism was described at the bedside in the 1870s; a reliable blood test for thyroid hormones came about a hundred years later. Nobody argues that these diseases began on the day the laboratory caught up. Even today, migraine and Parkinson's disease are diagnosed mainly by a doctor listening and examining. No one calls them imaginary.

The evidence for mental illness is of the same kind and is not small. These illnesses run in families; twin studies put the heritability of schizophrenia at around 80 per cent. They follow recognisable courses. They respond to specific medicines in controlled trials. Brain scans show differences between groups of patients and groups of healthy people.

What we lack is the instrument that turns this into a report for one person. The brain sits inside the skull and cannot be sampled like blood. Present tools, such as PET and MR spectroscopy, give only a rough view of dopamine, glutamate, serotonin and noradrenaline, and so far they separate groups, not individuals. It is also likely that these illnesses are not a matter of one chemical being high or low, in the way sugar is high in diabetes. They may be disorders of circuits, and circuits are harder to measure than levels.

That day will come, though no one can honestly say when. When it does, the wall between neurology and psychiatry will grow thinner, and both will sit more plainly under neuroscience. But the work of psychology will not disappear. A person with diabetes still has to change how he eats and lives, even though his sugar can be measured to a decimal point. A person with depression will still need someone to talk to, even when his brain can be measured.

Until then, the honest position is simple. The patient's suffering is the evidence. We do not have the test yet. That is our weakness, not the patient's.

All articles